I have to decide SEAGATE or MAXTOR

--- I heard a lot of well maxtor D740x, and have a great experience with Seagate .... I'm so as not to bother me ... I want your opinions ... I saw that many people have had trouble with noise the Maxtor ..... what you think --- Use the seagate ... I prefer! : P --- In my opinion Seagate for sure I had problems with Maxtor and I know people who also had problems ok. --- Alias ​​of the new seagate hds still have that cape rubber that protects your drive a bit --- In my opinion stick with a Segate Hd, both the Barracuda III or IV are excellent.
I've had several problems with the Maxtor HD's, mainly by the noise that bicinhos begin to take an hour to another. Would no doubt be a Seagate. : Wink: --- Ok .. how about Seagate Barracuda Any comment --- Seagate guy uses you do not repent, I had already all maxtor quantum
have problems, look for another brand of PC's most hd is seagate
not know these new D740 but i only see talk bad, we just need
be that neither the ibm-limited time to use during the day
my neighbor will be a seagate hd of 60gb or 80gb 7200 rpm
--- According to the magazine PC Extreme No 4 pg. 12-18, which brings a test of several models of HD's without doubt the most quality and more reliable today are those of 7200 rpm.
In this category the Maxtor and Western Digital JB series and BB and WB, with advantage to the couple to adopt technology Maxtor ATA 133 and were followed soon after by Seagate and Samsung.
So I get the Maxtor, I have an alias, I can not comment with much knowledge of the facts because it's my 1, the Quantum has got nothing to complain.
T more., --- I think you guys vain concondar me ... It is difficult to choose a HD eim .... but that thing would be .. .........!!! It seems that everything depends more on luck than judgment ... that mark this spoils the batch .... to ... pq not make a decent product once! --- Seagate Barracuda IV. --- I use maxtor, not hear it working (do not leave coolers: lol :: lol:). --- Look, I've used the Seagate, but rather the question of speed ATA 133 Maxtor D740x. Now ask yourself is one thing to test is different, not because many problems with Maxtor tiverão he sucks and that Seagate is better or virce versa. The best thing and try and see which does better for you. For remember that the same device can be doing better for some and not others!! --- Seegate already had the fame ma in the past, maxtor were the best to give problems, IBM idem, these things are well on, it's a lottery ... no one will be able to guess the media will have problems here 1 year even with rigorous testing of manufacturers
... I believe everything has a stage, and it seems that no one else ta sizzling of seegates
seithan .... ... --- At least here in my service the Maxtor RMA are giving enough ... (Hopefully not be my next!) --- Watch the dosi are good, but lately people have claimed much of Maxtor. I'd buy a Seagate.
Cheers, Marcelo Cruz --- Before you condemn a brand of hard disk, try to observe the conditions of transport and storage of the same with your vendor. For
, have witnessed cases where the motorcycle courier made a delivery of a HD that was alone in the trunk of the bike without any protection, just imagine what it must have come to the client.
: wink: --- I have 3 Hds Maxtor 20G, with / - 1 year of use last week one of them just died ... claims problems ... I picked up the soft maxtor's test, and he alleges errors in almost all tests.
spoke ... --- I agree with the opinions above, I've had a Maxtor and burned an hour to another. --- I saw in PC 4 Extreme Western Digital WD800BB that he looks good as hell, and a good alternative to the Maxtor, as this gives damn problem. You guys recommend --- Ja lost several Maxtor hard drives. Get a Seagate Barracuda V is hyper silent, super fast and very good! : P

Page 3 --- 8) Maxtor is a good brand, in which case you must choose between what has a good price ... --- I have two seagate hd's one of the other of 20GB 1.7GB (5 years and still has no signs of fatigue)
ah asked you if it comes with protective rubber band that he has been yes, and within a seashell (cover)
Seagate Rula much! --- Seagate! I
I'm already on my second HD brand, never had problems! --- I think the maxtor hds the faster but less durable than realized by now the seagates are a better choice --- I use HD soh of quantum ... for me the best h ... --- I have a Maxtor 40gb HD, never had problems with it! What about the noise, yet to do and hope it will not start! About Seagate can say anything because I never tried one! --- The Quantum was bought by Maxtor. I think HD is going very lucky. Who had a problem with the brands will speak ill of her, for sure .... I've always had
Quantum and Maxtor and never had performance issues, noise or crash .............. --- Dude ... I had a 7200 rpm Barracuda II who made much noise .. but it was very very fast and never had problems in 2 years of continuous use and a drop hehehehehehe! I changed the
D740X-L which is very quiet and very quick! So it was not yet three months .. to assess the durability of it. In reality this "harvest" of HD's Maxtor has a lot of new quantum technology is very new and that is, anything you ask them for now is speculation.
But so far nothing to complain about!